Three months into power in Britain, Labour Prime Minister Keir Starmer is already having to deal with criticism from within his own party. In the corridors of Labour’s annual gathering in Liverpool, northwest England, the mood is far from celebratory despite the party’s thumping election win in July.”We were all full of optimism. (But) some of the decisions the government has made, it took us back a bit,” one Labour member and veteran of party conferences, 75-year-old George Cumiskey, told AFP.
Jenny Ward, a 76-year-old activist, was unhappy with the government’s decision to eliminate winter fuel payments for 10 million pensioners, a move justified by Starmer as necessary to help fix the public finances.”It’s not what our party is like,” she said. Mark, a 64-year-old former transport worker, was more sympathetic.”They are in a tough place. They are doing the right thing in taking difficult decisions,” he told AFP.”We probably won’t know for two or three years if they have worked out,” he added. “You need to have a little bit of patience.”But patience appeared thin among younger activists desperate for change.”We’ve had that from the Tories these last 14 years: ‘Oh, the country’s got no money, so we’re gonna have to cut all the public services,'” said Fraser, a 21-year-old student.”At the end day, that rhetoric just doesn’t work.”On Monday, activists from the Unite union demonstrated outside the conference to demand more taxes on the wealthiest.
Since Starmer became Labour leader in April 2020 he has brought the party to the centre and marginalised or purged left-wingers including his predecessor, socialist Jeremy Corbyn. The Momentum movement, which supported Corbyn and calls for a socialist government, has lost its considerable influence over the party’s board and currently holds little sway. “There’s that battle between a Labour leadership that is very cautious, and a Labour membership which wants to spend money and do exciting projects,” said Jonathan Tonge, politics professor at the University of Liverpool.- ‘Ruthless’ -Since winning power, Starmer has ruled with an iron fist over his 400-plus members of parliament in the House of Commons lower chamber.
He did not hesitate to suspend seven of them in July for voting against a controversial cap on child benefits.”Keir Starmer as prime minister is being very, very ruthless with his own party. He’s saying back me or you’re sacked,” Tonge told AFP. On Monday the party leadership postponed until the last day of the conference, when many members will have already left, a vote tabled by two unions against the abolition of the fuel payments for retirees. Momentum denounced the decision to push back the vote as a “pathetic manoeuvre by a party elite running scared of its own affiliates”.
A few left-wing voices do manage to be heard, most notably Diane Abbott, the first black woman to be elected to the UK parliament and a hero for many in the party.”For the moment, I think most of the new MPs, and there’s a lot of very new MPs, will probably be following what they’re told (by the leadership),” said Nottingham University politics professor Steven Fielding. He thinks that could change after the October 30 budget, which Starmer has warned will be “painful” for Britons.”If things are still looking a bit ropy, they’ll be looking for concrete things that the Labour government is actually doing that will improve the lives of the people that voted for them,” Fielding added.
Unions — traditionally big financial backers of Labour — have voiced criticism of the new government, particularly over the winter fuel payments, but they are not causing too much trouble yet.”The unions will continue to support this Labour government because the Labour government has promised them a new set of workers’ rights. So the trade unions are on side at the moment,” said Tonge.
Despite agreements on wage increases for public sector workers, unions still dangle the prospect of further strike action. More discreetly, the Unite union has stopped financing the party leadership, the Financial Times recently revealed. It now concentrates funds on nearly 90 MPs, most of whom are considered to be more left-wing.
Tue, 24 Sep 2024 13:16:46 GMT
