Third-Biggest U.S. County Wins Vote-by-Mail Ruling in Texas

(Bloomberg) — The nation’s third-biggest county won another round in its vote-by-mail battle with Texas’s Republican leadership, when a state appeals court ruled it can send out 2.4 million applications to residents of Houston.

The clerk of Harris County, the most populous in the emerging swing state, was given the green light on Friday by a three-judge, Democratic panel.

“A voter would be less likely to engage in fraud using the application sent by the county clerk because it has an official imprimatur, contains extensive explanations for what qualifies a voter to receive a mall ballot under the law, and is accompanied by text and red-siren graphics traditionally associated with danger and caution in general,” the panel wrote in a unanimous ruling rejecting the state’s argument that the clerk, Chris Hollins, was luring voters into criminal conduct.

“The state’s argument is based on mere conjecture,” the judges of the 14th Texas Court of Appeals wrote. “There is, in this record, no proof that voters will intentionally violate the election code and no proof that voters will fail to understand the mailer and intentionally commit a felony.”

Hollins can’t hit the mailbox quite yet.

The all-Republican Texas Supreme Court had already blocked him from acting until it can review the matter itself.

Attorney General Ken Paxton said in a statement he would seek a full review of Hollins’s plan from the state Supreme Court.

“I look forward to demonstrating to the court how Hollins’ plan violates Texas law,” Paxton said in a statement.

Hollins’s spokeswoman Elizabeth Lewis didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Texas is an important battleground in the national vote-by-mail conflict spearheaded on the GOP side by President Donald Trump, who has repeatedly claimed, without evidence, that widespread use of mailed ballots leads to rampant voter fraud.

If Democrats can tilt the traditionally red state blue, they will cost Trump all 38 of its electoral votes and could even realign Texas’s large congressional delegation and capture control of the state legislature and redistricting process.

Houston, for its part, is the nation’s fourth-largest city, one of its most diverse and the launchpad for the Democratic Party’s effort to flip Texas in November.

Both Texas and the state’s Republican Party are challenging Hollins’s mass-mailing plan, which they say will confuse voters by encouraging millions of people who don’t qualify to vote by mail.

Texas’s Republican leadership claims the legislature narrowly crafted mail-ballot rules to give special assistance to disabled, absentee and senior-citizen voters without enabling widespread voter fraud.

Texas’s Supreme Court recently ruled that voters can decide for themselves whether their health allows them to go to the polls during the coronavirus pandemic. Harris County’s mail-ballot applications clearly explain who can and can’t vote by mail.

(Updates with Attorney General’s comment)

For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com

©2020 Bloomberg L.

P.