German Regulator Faults Adler’s Accounts for a Second Time

(Bloomberg) — Germany’s financial regulator BaFin found further errors in the accounts of Adler Group SA, a setback for the embattled landlord that’s fighting to regain investor confidence.

Adler Real Estate AG shouldn’t have consolidated ADO Properties SA in its 2019 accounts and thereby inflated its balance sheet by €3.9 billion ($4 billion) and earnings by €543 million, BaFin said in a statement on Thursday.

The landlord said it does not share the regulator’s view and is appealing the decision.

Adler has been in turmoil for over a year as it seeks to fight off a short-seller’s allegations of systemic fraud. It’s replaced executives as it seeks to improve governance and sold assets to shore up its finances. 

An Adler-initiated review by KPMG didn’t find evidence of systemic fraud, though it didn’t disprove some of the short-seller allegations.

The firm’s accounts are key to its efforts to win back the trust of investors, sapped further after the resignation of KPMG as its auditor following its report.

BaFin said Adler Real Estate’s 33% indirect shareholding in ADO Properties was insufficient to give it control of the firm, given ADO was going to acquire Adler Real Estate itself. 

Adler said it “was and is firmly convinced that the aforementioned indirect shareholding represents a de facto controlling majority taking into account the usual attendance at annual general meetings of ADO Properties SA.” The company “continues to maintain the full accuracy and correctness of the audited consolidated financial statements for the 2019 financial year.”

BaFin said Adler’s report didn’t provide sufficient information on the risks associated with a faulty assessment of control over ADO Properties.

Adler didn’t state that its loan-to-value figure would have risen to about 70% without consolidating the firm, the regulator said. That’s a key metric for investors because it helps determine a real estate company’s financial health.

The findings come three months after BaFin accused the firm of erroneous accounting by booking a property sale at a price that was roughly double a fair valuation.

Adler said at the time that it would appeal the regulator’s ruling.

BaFin has been investigating Adler since August 2021. That was before short seller Fraser Perring’s Viceroy Research questioned the valuations Adler placed on its holdings and deals between the landlord and companies linked to some of its backers, including the extended family of Austrian financier Cevdet Caner.

The German regulator said its investigation of Adler Real Estate’s 2019, 2020, and 2021 accounts is continuing.

Adler said that it’s in “good and constructive dialog” with BaFin. Still, in the interest of transparency and the company and its stakeholders, the firm “would like BaFin to provide a swift overall assessment” for 2019.   

(Updates with BaFin statement from the second paragraph)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.

P.