(Bloomberg) — Rudy Giuliani’s efforts to present “expert” witnesses who promoted baseless election fraud claims in his legal ethics case in Washington are facing a challenge from disciplinary authorities.
Giuliani’s lawyers plan to call as many as 16 witnesses, including the one-time New York City mayor himself, at a hearing set for early December. The District of Columbia’s Office of Disciplinary Counsel is objecting to five witnesses being offered as experts, saying Giuliani’s lawyers didn’t provide required expert reports or other information necessary to qualify expert testimony, according to a notice made public Tuesday.
The disciplinary counsel’s office — the enforcement arm of the Washington Bar — has charged Giuliani with violating local attorney ethics rules by pressing a “frivolous” post-election challenge in Pennsylvania on behalf of former President Donald Trump.
Giuliani has denied wrongdoing, arguing he acted in good faith in seeking to invalidate mail-in ballots at the time.
Giuliani’s witness list features Trump allies who boosted election denial claims. His lawyers offered short summaries of what each person would testify about, noting some who would discuss “voting irregularities” and “alleged illegalities.” There has been no evidence of widespread fraud in the election and dozens of courts rejected challenges to President Joe Biden’s wins in key states, including Pennsylvania.
Expert testimony typically gets greater weight in legal proceedings.
Courts — or, in this case, a special committee that hears evidence in attorney discipline cases and makes recommendations — require parties to prove an expert’s qualifications. Experts typically prepare written reports about what they plan to testify about, and the opposing side can review that and challenge their expertise.
For two proposed witnesses set to testify about their analysis of “irregularities” — former Trump trade adviser Peter Navarro and John Droz Jr. — the disciplinary counsel’s office says Giuliani’s lawyers did provide written reports.
But they argued Tuesday that those reports lacked information about the witnesses’ qualifications and a required certification statement. The office said it would lift its objections if Giuliani’s lawyers provided the missing information.
For three other witnesses, however, the disciplinary authorities said it wasn’t clear if Giuliani planned to call them as “experts” at all, but that the “cryptic descriptions” in his witness list suggested they would.
The disciplinary counsel’s office objected, saying Giuliani’s lawyers had failed to provide any reports or other documentation.
One of the witnesses at issue, Phil Waldron, would testify about “methods” used to analyze “irregularities and alleged voting illegalities,” according to Giuliani’s witness list. The other two individuals, Shiva Ayyadurai and Russell Ramsland, would discuss “statistical analysis” of voting results and records.
Giuliani’s lawyers John Leventhal and Barry Kamins, both retired judges, didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
©2022 Bloomberg L.
P.
