Trump Wraps Up Three-Year Push to Gut Auto Efficiency Rules

(Bloomberg) — The Trump administration on Tuesday took the final step in its three-year quest to dismantle Obama-era fuel-economy and greenhouse gas emissions regulations for automobiles, a process that has fractured carmakers, enraged environmentalists and sparked courtroom battles.

Under a rule unveiled Tuesday, the administration will require automakers to boost the fuel efficiency of new cars by 1.5% per year through 2026, a major relaxation of previous mandates demanding improvements of roughly 5% annually.

The effort has sparked a furious response by consumer and environmental advocates, who accused President Donald Trump’s administration of obliterating the most effective policy ever enacted to reduce greenhouse gas emissions linked to climate change.

The new rule is “a deliberate decision to steer us at high speed toward a more dangerous climate,” said Ken Kimmell, president of the Union of Concerned Scientists. “It also cedes American leadership in vehicle manufacturing, putting the automakers at risk in a global market.”

The initiative has been marked by tumult and repeated delays amid criticism from academics, environmental groups and even the Environmental Protection Agency’s own science advisers that the move to weaken the standards was underpinned by shoddy analysis.

Under the new requirements, 2026 model-year fleet cars, trucks and SUVs will average roughly 40 miles per gallon as opposed to closer to 47 mpg under the previous standards.

“As we have done numerous times over the last three years, today’s announcement again delivers on President Trump’s promise to remove and replace undue — and in this case, unrealistic — regulatory burdens,” EPA Administrator Andrew Wheeler said in statement.

Wheeler said the new standards would save lives and money, while giving motorists more choices about the cars they drive.

He blamed the previous standards for driving up the cost of new vehicles and pushing Americans to hold on to old, less-safe cars longer.

Because the standards set a floor, not a ceiling, on fuel economy, consumers still have the choice to buy hybrids, electric vehicles or other highly-efficient vehicles, said James Owens, acting head of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. “American families can’t get the benefits of safety and better environmental standards of new vehicles if they can’t afford the sticker price in the first place,” he said.

Federal agencies completed a critical piece of the Trump administration plan last year: a rule stripping California of its power to set limits on auto emissions of greenhouse gases that are stricter than those of the national government and encourage electric vehicles.

White House officials had been considering the move as early as February 2017, before Trump announced before a gathering of auto workers near Detroit that his administration would re-evaluate the standards brokered by former President Barack Obama, automakers and California officials.

California and environmental groups have challenged last year’s move against the state and litigation is still underway.

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra on Tuesday threatened more to come, calling the measure “an unlawful attempt to change our clean-car standards” that runs afoul of the Clean Air Act.

“The federal government should be in the business of applying this law rather than violating it,” Becerra said.

Environmental groups also vowed to fight the plan in court, arguing the final regulation violates federal law requiring the government to set fuel economy standards at the maximum feasible level.

Automakers are already producing electric vehicles that don’t generate tailpipe emissions, which they say proves the standards could have been made tougher, not weakened now.

Trump’s initiative has fractured the auto industry. Ford Motor Co., BMW AG, Honda Motor Co. and Volkswagen AG last summer vowed to meet voluntary, more-stringent emissions goals set by California and said they wouldn’t support legal challenges against the state.

Ford doubled down on that promise Tuesday, with vice president of sustainability Bob Holycross stressing the automaker continues “to believe this path is what’s best for our customers, the environment and the short- and long-term health of the auto industry.”

Other major carmakers including General Motors Co., Toyota Motor Corp. and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV meanwhile backed the Trump administration’s position that California’s authority to regulate tailpipe greenhouse gas emissions should be revoked.

John Bozzella, president of the Alliance for Automotive Innovation that represents nearly all major carmakers, said that the industry has consistently called for year-over-year fuel economy and greenhouse gas improvements.

“We also recognize that the standards that were put in place 10 years ago or so are no longer appropriate in light of shifting market conditions and consumer preferences,” Bozzella said.

The final rule responds to some automakers’ concerns by largely preserving existing flexibilities baked into the Obama-era program, including allowing companies to claim credit for improvements to vehicle air conditioning systems.

The EPA also opted to extend an existing incentive for electric vehicles, instead of eliminating it as some conservatives had hoped. However, the administration is also taking action to propel natural gas vehicles by effectively giving them extra credit under the program.

Some conservatives who had argued for wiping the standards away altogether still rallied behind the final result, arguing it creates a more realistic fuel efficiency program that preserves consumer choice while saving motorists money.

The final plan is “pretty meaty,” said Tom Pyle, head of the American Energy Alliance. “They’re not freezing” the standards, and instead “it’s a reduction of the wildly unachievable rule that the previous administration rushed through.”

(Updates with details on rule and comments from Ford and California attorney general, from eighth paragraph.)

For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com

©2020 Bloomberg L.

P.