U.K. Scientists Advised Ministers to Ease Lockdown ‘Gradually’

(Bloomberg) —

The public will lose faith in the U. K.’s coronavirus strategy if ministers ease the lockdown and then impose restrictions again later, according to advice from government experts.

A paper released by the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies advised ministers to try a gradual easing of the measures when the coronavirus lockdown is eventually lifted, because a stop-start approach could lead to a loss of trust.

The suggestion is made in a cache of documents released on Tuesday, which reveal details of the U.

K.’s evolving strategy for fighting the Covid-19 outbreak. The papers showed:

  • As Boris Johnson boasted March 3 of shaking hands with “everybody” on a hospital visit, a SAGE paper said: “Government should advise against greetings such as shaking hands and hugging”
  • On Feb. 4, SAGE estimated the true scale of the outbreak in China to be 10 times higher than officials were confirming at the time
  • Modeling presented to a meeting on March 26 — three days after the lockdown began — predicted an “optimistic scenario” of 10,000 deaths in the first wave of the outbreak.

    There are now about 30,000 deaths in the U. K.

  • As Johnson ordered the national lockdown on March 23, SAGE experts said it was not clear whether the strict measures would work due to “huge uncertainty” about the pandemic
  • A paper presented at a meeting on March 23 predicted London’s hospital intensive care units would be overwhelmed within days, even with the lockdown, and warned that infections were spreading faster than expected
  • Debate around “herd immunity” may have undermined instructions to avoid passing virus to other people, SAGE experts warned in a paper presented to the March 23 meeting. “A substantial number of people still do not feel sufficiently personally threatened,” they said

The documents were released as Johnson’s government prepares to review its lockdown measures which have been in place for the past six weeks.

The prime minister is facing calls to ease the restrictions and get the economy moving again, while at the same time ensuring workers are kept safe and working environments are sufficiently protected.

Easing Lockdown

An April 1 paper on how to relax the lockdown measures shows government scientists examined tactics to ease restrictions and then tighten them again. About a third of the four-page document is redacted.

“If strict restrictions are retained for months and then abruptly eased and people are told it is safe to resume social contact they will expect this to mean that the risk of infection has ceased or significantly reduced,” they wrote. “If there is then an increase in infection rates that necessitates a reintroduction of restrictions this is likely to be seen as a serious failure of policy and trust in public health advice will be lost.”

Instead, the scientists advocated “trialling easing restrictions very gradually when epidemiologically indicated while clearly explaining why these particular activities are being resumed and how risks must be controlled if these activities are to be maintained.”

The document was one of several published by Johnson’s government after ministers came under pressure to be more open about the scientific advice they have received on how to deal with the pandemic.

Johnson has insisted throughout the crisis that his actions have been guided by “the science.”

A government spreadsheet listing all the documents discussed at SAGE meetings lists 120 papers, but to date, just 28 have been published, including 16 on Tuesday. Papers that have not been published include one from February on when to stop contact tracing, and another on the impact of sporting events on the transmission of the virus, which was debated on the final day of a four-day horse-racing meeting that drew a quarter of a million spectators.

Other unpublished documents cover school closures, the use of face masks, a comparison of the U.

K. response with that of Italy, and one discussed on March 26 entitled “Planning scenarios for the next six months.”

For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com

©2020 Bloomberg L. P.